NAFEMS benchmark validation

The NAFEMS problems are the standard answer to "is this solver trustworthy?". FEA Lab ships them as a runnable suite, not a claim in a brochure.

What the suite covers

LE1 elliptic membrane, Cook's membrane, the pinched cylinder with mixed membrane/bending elements, quarter-patched plate, MITC4 shell formulations, distributed loading, and plasticity equivalence cases. Each case declares its reference values, so the comparison is against published data rather than a stored answer key.

Why it matters for pinching

The pinched cylinder is the classic shell benchmark because it is brutally sensitive: the same geometry gives a different answer depending on whether bending and membrane response are locked correctly. Curved 4-node shells (Shell4C and Shell4EASC, with warping projection and consistent Node6 rotation transformations) converge monotonically to 100.05% and 98.99% of the MacNeal–Harder diaphragm reference (1.8248e-5 m) at 32×32, while un-projected flat Shell4 and 8-node Shell8C remain flagged untrusted-3d in the accuracy floor table rather than quietly excluded.

Open the interactive workspace — mesh, solve, validate and export in the browser.

Start a guided solve
FEA Lab
Loading analysis environment…